Thinking of Returning Your New Puppy to the Shelter/Breeder? Please Read This First

Puppy Regret: Friendly advice from someone who's been there

By Jake Buvala | Last updated: November 10, 2026

Dear puppy parent,

So you’ve adopted a puppy who has turned out to be a little terror, and you’re thinking of finding them a new home. Despite your best efforts, some problem has come up. Maybe they:

  • Won’t stop biting
  • Freak out in their crate or pen
  • Are terrible at walking on leash
  • Try to eat all the rocks, trash, and assorted other horrors on the street
  • Won’t stop pooping all over your house
  • Terrorize your children and your other pets

Or maybe they just require way more work than you expected.

I feel your pain, and I’m not here to guilt-trip you. The last thing you need is an “ohmygod how could you! A dog is a lifetime commitment!” lecture.

This is just some friendly advice from someone who’s been there.

I’d like to introduce you to my first puppy, Friday.

A tiny demon, ready to steal your soul

I had dreamed about getting my very own dog for years. As soon as I got one, I regretted everything

Friday was an eight-week old German shepherd mix, tucked away in the last kennel of the local animal shelter. She was an adorable goofball. She was everything I wanted – or so I thought until we actually brought her home.

It only took a few days for my feelings to change.

Friday would bite, tear at clothing and chew on EVERYTHING. She never listened. She had an attention span of three seconds. She whined all night long. She peed on my bed. She didn’t seem to like me much.

The feeling was mutual.

I thought I’d somehow ended up with the worst puppy in the world.

I was deeply discouraged. This was not at all what I imagined this would be like. I was sick of the whole thing and I just wanted my life to go back to normal.


Fast forward an undisclosed number of years later, I’m now a professional dog trainer who runs online training programs for people in this exact position.

(Yes, somehow my experience with Friday made me want to pursue this as a career, instead of running screaming in the opposite direction. What can I say. Some people like pain)

And there’s this weirdly specific “spiral of doom” we see over and over again. A sequence of unfortunate thoughts and events that can lead people – who never thought they’d be the type of person to get rid of their dog – to be tempted to get rid of their dog.

Maybe you can relate.

The spiral of doom

It goes something like this:

You thought you were prepared.

This wasn’t an impulse decision. You did your research, or you grew up with dogs. You knew there would be challenges. Dealing with play biting, house training, making sure the kids stick to their “I’ll feed him and walk him every day” promises, introducing your older dog to their new little friend, etc.

But by day three, you’ve got whiplash because it’s not just hard work. It’s RELENTLESS.

You do the “hard work” of daily training, exercise, feeding, but what about the in-between times? The other 22 hours a day where you can’t let the pup out of your sight because if you do, he’s destroying things or screaming his head off?

And you might be able to tough all that out, but what really gets you is…

The challenges you expected are SO MUCH WORSE than you expected.

The play biting isn’t gentle. It’s constant and painful and doesn’t seem like play at all. 

You thought the struggle with your kids would be getting them to clean up the dog poop in the yard on a somewhat regular basis. You didn’t realize they’d be scared of the puppy because the biting was so bad.

You were worried your older dog might get jealous. You didn’t realize the puppy would harass them at every possible chance. 

And of course, everyone else makes it look easy.

The neighbor’s puppy doesn’t bite. Your friend’s dog was “so easy to train.” Every video on social media features a sweet, angelic ball of fluff who learn 50 tricks by the time they’re four months old. 

You try everything to get this puppy’s behavior under control, but nothing really works.

Not positive reinforcement, not redirection, not scolding, not the advice from the vet or your friends or the trainers on Instagram who say shit like “just give them a chew toy when they bite” like it’s the simplest thing in the goddamn world. 

And because this experience has been so vastly different than anticipated, you think:

“Either something’s wrong with me…”

Maybe you’re not cut out for this.

“…or something’s wrong with this puppy”

This puppy must be unusually difficult.

A fair assumption to make, seeing as how they’re seemingly immune to all the dog training advice in the world.

You might look at puppy training programs like ours and think that looks cute, but I’m pretty sure those trainers have never dealt with a situation as unique as mine or a puppy as beyond hope as mine.

You start wondering if it’s already too late.

“Alright,” you concede in response to the ironical tone you detected in that last paragraph. “There might be hope for puppies LIKE mine. But I’m afraid it’s too late for us specifically. I’ve made too many mistakes, there are too many hard feelings. We’ve missed our chance.”

Returning the puppy starts to look like the only way out.

You can’t keep living like this.

You feel terrible about the idea of giving your puppy back, but you’re also desperate. You want your old life back. You want the puppy to be happy, too! They deserve someone who can give them what they need.

Soooo we end up at thoughts like this:

I should return them quickly while they’re still little and cute, to give them the best chance at being adopted by someone else.

(That’s a very kind thought, btw. It tells me you’re an empathetic person who truly wants to do what’s best for this dog. You’re trying to make a compassionate, responsible choice in an incredibly difficult moment)

Here’s what you should know (and what I wished I’d known with my first puppy)

I’m sure your head’s a mess right now.

Let’s untangle things.

Some of what you’re experiencing is a normal part of adjusting to life with a new dog

Getting a puppy disrupts every part of your life. You don’t get much sleep, all your daily routines get screwed up. They take up a ton of time and energy.

In other words, it’s kind of a big change.

The human brain hates change.  

It takes one look at that puppy peeing on the carpet and starts slamming the panic button. “Ummm absolutely not. ABORT MISSION.” 

So to some extent, complicated feelings or “puppy blues” are pretty standard. Even professional dog trainers can have moments of thinking ugh, why did I do this AGAIN when we get a new dog.

Those thoughts doesn’t inherently mean something’s wrong. Feeling like you made a huge mistake doesn’t mean you actually have.

And we don’t expect anyone to be full of joy and infinite patience at every moment. Setbacks and shitty days are part of the puppy-raising experience.

Having said that:

Sometimes there’s more going on than normal puppy blues. You might be stuck in what we call the “What The **** Was I Thinking?!” trap

This is a more intense kind of distress. 

Symptoms of the WTFWIT trap:

  • You’re not just having occasional bad days. You’re either feeling persistently unhappy or resentful about life with your puppy, or your unhappiness has become genuinely intense and is taking a serious toll on your mental health. (Or both)
  • Things are getting worse, not better. It’s one thing to have a few training setbacks. Progress isn’t linear, as they say. But overall, life with your puppy should be gradually improving.
  • Your puppy’s behavior is the main source of your distress. You’re not just thrown off by your routine getting disrupted.
  • You feel like this dog doesn’t really like you. And/or you don’t like them.
  • All your interactions seem to end in frustration. Training, cuddling, walks… pretty much all of it sucks.
  • You’ve lost your patience and treated them harshly, or been afraid you might.

If you’re experiencing at least one of these, you might be caught in the trap.

This is not a “just give it time” situation. Escaping the trap requires you to make some changes.

But don’t panic. There’s a lot we can do to turn this ship around. 

I’ll give it to ya straight: if your distress is centered on any of the following puppy behaviors, something about the approach you’re taking is making this harder than it needs to be

  • Biting. Biting you, your kids, your other pets.
  • Crying when left alone. When you put them in the crate, leave the house, or even just leave the room.
  • General hyperactivity. Exercising them somehow makes them MORE crazy??
  • Not listening and/or ignoring you.
  • House training drama. Like frequent accidents indoors, refusing to pee outside but peeing as soon as you come inside, or a training process that drags on for ages. Potty training takes a while to become 100% solid, but it shouldn’t take weeks to see significant progress.
  • Nighttime drama. Keeping you up night after night or refusing to settle down. Yes, some sleep deprivation is normal when you have a baby of any species. But again, it shouldn’t take weeks to see progress.

If stuff like this is what’s making you consider throwing in the towel, I have good news: there’s a very good chance you are suffering unnecessarily.

I can almost guarantee that something about the approach you’re using is making worse.

But this isn’t your fault. The Dog World is loud and judgmental and full of conflicting opinions. It can be hard to know who to listen to or pick out an actual plan in all that noise.

Sometimes the culprit is a misunderstanding or an incorrect assumption about what’s going on with the puppy.

(This was the case with Friday and me. I thought she was being stubborn and dominant, and I needed to be firmer. Now I know she was struggling as much as I was. She wasn’t fighting me – she needed help. I wish I could go back and tell myself that)

Sometimes the culprit is a training method that’s backfiring.

And sometimes, ironically, the culprit is the very advice meant to help you get through the puppy blues. If you’ve been told that puppyhood is supposed to suck and that everyone goes through this, you might assume that you have only two options: get rid of puppy or accept being miserable)

You probably haven’t missed your chance. You might just be in the “WOW WHAT A DISASTER” part of the story before the redemption arc unfolds

Starting with the wrong approach is super common. You’re fine. Usually it takes a few simple tweaks to start improving things.

A concrete example:

My kids or my puppy? Amy’s dilemma

Amy contacted us because her new puppy was so wild and bitey that her children decided they wanted nothing to do with him. They started spending most of their time sequestered in areas of the house the puppy couldn’t get to.

And of course, the puppy freaked out whenever he was alone. So Amy felt torn. Like she was forced to spend most of her time with the puppy, away from the kids. She was drowning in guilt about missing family time that she’d never get back.

That’s understandable. But as we talked, it became clear that some of the advice she’d been given was backfiring and making the biting worse. This led her to assume she only had two choices: kids or dog.

This is why you gotta be careful with common puppy blues advice like “just give it time. It gets better!”

If Amy had continued doing what she was doing, things would not have gotten better. 

But all we needed to do was put together a plan that actually reduced the biting, let the family (puppy included) spend time in the same space peacefully, and also helped the puppy be more comfortable being on his own.

I won’t get into the “how-to” specifics, since that’ll be different for everyone. Besides, that’s not the point of this post.

We’re not talking about dog training today.

We’re talking about the monsters in your head.

Because all the dog training advice in the world is useless if you don’t even believe there’s a point in trying.

A bad beginning doesn’t have to define your entire story

Before you brought this critter home, you had a specific vision in your head of what puppy life was going to be like, right? Dreams for everything you’d do together.

Reality hasn’t exactly lived up to your dreams, and it’s okay to be upset about that. You can’t go back and change those first few days or weeks.

But you can change what happens next.

We see this all the time.

People come to us feeling defeated, convinced they’ve messed everything up.

We help them figure out what needs to change. We see them make progress. We see relationships improve. We see overwhelmed people who once couldn’t imagine enjoying life with their dogs become completely smitten with them.

I’m not saying you just have to suck it up and keep doing what you’re doing, pushing through the misery because somehow it’ll all magically get better someday.

Because it probably won’t get better on its own. And even if it would, you don’t have to just suffer for months in the meantime. You can enjoy life with your puppy now.

What if you’re seriously considering returning your puppy?

Rehoming is the right choice sometimes. The honorable choice, even.

We’ve worked with a few amazing families who tried their best, but ultimately determined that they were not a good match for their puppies. They made the tough decision to find them a better home. No shame in that.

But those situations are rare.

The majority of people we work with who are stuck in the What The **** Was I Thinking trap just need to change some things for life to get easier.

The problem is that when you’re in the middle of this chaos, it can be hard to figure out what’s real. 

Are the thoughts like I can’t do this, I’ve made a mistake, I changed my mind, this dog deserves better a reflection of how you truly feel… or are the monsters in your head just saying whatever shit it takes to drag you back to familiar territory?

Is this puppy truly too much for you to handle, or are the two of you just stuck in a pattern that’s actively sabotaging you?

Tricky questions to answer when your brain’s got you feeling like you’re being chased by a tiger.

Our advice:

Before you make a such a big decision in fight-or-flight mode, give yourself the chance to try something different. Take a breath and let the ol’ nervous system chill out.

And get some help instead of trying to figure all this out yourself.

The right dog behavior professional can get you on the right track and help you figure out if your situation is actually as impossible as it seems.

We can help, if you want.

A good place to start is our ebook I Got a Puppy. What Was I Thinking.

It’s a quick-and-dirty guide designed to get the brain monsters to shut the hell up so you can figure out how you ACTUALLY feel. It includes a few of our tried-and-true tactics for reducing hyper crazy bitey puppy behavior. 

These tactics function like a test. Okay, so you’re afraid that you’re really not cut out for this or your puppy really is beyond hope?

Okay cool. Let’s find out!

Try the tactics and see what happens. They’re not going to fix everything, but they might make a dent. If they do, there ya go – you have proof that there’s hope.

Proof that you can do this.

Or you might realize that keeping this dog really is a bad idea. If you decide that rehoming is the best option, you can feel good knowing you made that choice with a clear head, not out of desperation.

These days, it’s nearly impossible to imagine that the dog I loved so dearly was, at one point, the puppy I thought I hated

Friday lived to be eleven years old. She was the sweetest dog you’d ever meet.

All the puppyhood nonsense that made me so angry is now a very distant memory. A memory that I can laugh at, mostly. Since we’re being honest, it wasn’t a total “and then they lived happily ever after!” story.

I made a lot of mistakes with her. Mistakes that affected our relationship and her behavior for years. She’s a big reason I became a dog trainer – to turn these regrets into something useful.

Still, my point stands: no matter how all-encompassing the puppy nonsense feels when you’re in the thick of it, it’s nothing compared to the greatness in store if you can get through the rough patches.

I believe in you. You can do this – and you don’t have to do it alone.

Hang in there.

-Jake

Dog trainer and co-founder of the 3 Lost Dogs Academy

(Who, for some reason, voluntarily adopted five more puppies after Friday)

Get our ebook:

I Got a Puppy. What Was I Thinking?!

  • Reduce your puppy's biting and hyperactive, out-of-control behavior (without having to do any frustrating training exercises)

  • Get out of the doom spiral and let go of some of the guilt, frustration and "WHAT HAVE I DONE" panic

  • Start building a strong bond with your pup, even if it feels like they don't even like you right now (and you don't like them)

Now look – this isn’t a magic fix and it’s definitely not going to solve ALL your puppy problems.

But we know you’re exhausted and you don’t have the time or energy to work your way through yet another lengthy puppy care guide or watch another ten training videos.

So this isn’t that.

It’s a quick-and-dirty guide to the things you need right the hell now to get back on your feet, start making progress, and prove to yourself that you really can do this.